All posts by Kirby Hogenmiller

Just kill the dogs. There only one dog worth feeling guilty about killing and that’s Bear. He shows up at the hospital at the end of Ellie day 2 and Midway through Ellie day three.

You can throw bottles or bricks somewhere near them to knock them off your scent or lure them away from you. You can also usually kill them with one shot from your silencer or bow. You can also kill their handler first and then kill the dog because the Dog will mourn the handler which gives you a chance to take them out. Usually the dog mourning the handler doesn’t alert the other people as fast as the handler mourning the dog.

I was sad but didn’t Cry.

It would have been more reasonable if she simply went for Abby and not go and kill every single one of her friends. With Jordan there wasn’t anything she could do about that since he would have killed Dina. With Nora I guess there wasn’t much she could do there either since Nora ran off thus beginning a deadly chase. But with Owen and Mel that whole situation could have been avoided if they did what Owen suggested and just talk about it. However I believe Ellie was too blinded by hate at that point. I don’t support what she did since only Killing Abby would have been an eye for an eye rather then take it a whole lot farther as well as the fact that the cycle of revenge never goes anywhere.

Nvm I submitted it to their support page

In my Opinion Abbys assault rifle with three round burst is the most overwhelming weapon. Not only does it melt enemies but it’s very accurate especially when scoped. By the way I didn’t put the flame thrower on here because I only get 6 slots....

No she isnt harder to fight in the end if you upgrade it will be harder for you to play as her though if you don’t upgrade

Ok anyone who is picking Seattle Ellie or Jackson instead of Seattle Abby must hate Abby because Seattle Abby is definitely the most fun section.

Yeah we Agree to disagree. The whole decade has past thing may have some merit but I just can’t see that being the final product if a third game is made.

I’m not trying to go by good or bad peoples narrative heck we all know that Ellie for sure was not the good person in most of Part II as well as Abby when she tortured Joel to death. What I’m trying to say is that the plot you are talking about with Abby and Lev would not make sense in part III and I don’t think Naughty Dog would wanna make us do a 180 on Abby just so we can do a 360 and hate her some more. Think about it Abby who was a killing machine In Part II and was essentially Isaacs second in commend redeemed herself in order to save two young kids in Yara and Lev and even betrayed the WLF because Isaac essentially was forcing Abby to choose between the life of a teen or the WLF. If Abby is established as some character who isn’t willing to kill kids why on earth would she all of a sudden come to Jackson and be ok with Killing everyone including children? As well as Lev who stopped Abby from Killing a pregnant women even when Abby wanted to kill Dina cause Ellie killed Mel? I don’t buy that Lev all of a sudden would be ok with killing anyone as well as Abby and it would just feel weird and out of place and it would feel like what we did in Part II didn’t happen as all. It’s more then someone being good or bad for Christ sake Batman is like my favorite superhero and fictional character of all time and he always blurs the lines a little bit between good and evil. Papa Joel used to be a hunter and probably killed all sorts of innocent people to the point that Tommy had nightmares and i still feel for Joel. I’m not saying I don’t like your game because Abby and Lev would be bad guys I don’t like it because it doesn’t feel like it would make sense based on what we know of their characters from the second game and what we experienced with them.

Ehh we can agree to disagree then on this because like I said I would not want to play a game where all of a sudden Lev and Abby come back and kill everyone especially when I played a whole game where both Ellie and Abby realize how the cycle of Revenge doesn’t fulfill anything except cause more pain and that it need to be broken. I feel like a game that tried to make players sympathize with Abby in Part II would essentially be retconned if Abby, Lev, and the fireflies just show up and burn down and kill almost everyone in Jackson. Essentially all the fans who hated the second game would be coming out of the woodwork to crap on Abby and Lev as well as reward fans who sent Laura Bailey death threats because they hated Abby Killing Joel. Those fans essentially would be placated to by going in the direction you wanna go with Abby and Lev in Part III and I feel Like Neal Druckman and Naughty Dog wouldn’t want to do that.

I like the plot for the most part except the part where Abby and Lev and the firefly are the bad guys. I feel like that would be an insult to their character arcs to from the last game if that was the case and I’d boycott part III if that was the case. Id much rather prefer that some other group like fedra or maybe even the WLF came or another group attacked Jackson and did al those things. Then midway during the journey JJ gets bit by an infected and it turns out he’s immune. Eventually towards the end of the game Ellie and JJ in a big sort of confrontation with the enemy gets saved by the fireflies led by Abby and Lev and eventually the fireflies upon learning of JJ immunity as well as knowing that Ellie is immune wishes to use both of them to make a cure once they find a doctor which would cost them their lives. However Abby makes a deal with Ellie saying that “I know I haven’t always done the right thing and I know you hate me but here’s my proposal.” Abby essentially makes a deal that Ellie and JJ will be able to live safely with the fireflies and live in relative freedom with the condition that if the fireflies find a doctor who can make a vaccine Ellie will willingly sacrifice herself for a cure in exchange for JJ and his survival. Thus Ellie comes full circle in understanding why Joel did what he did and can also fulfill what she always wanted to do while protecting the person she loves most. The game ends with Ellie saying yes or agreeing to Abbys terms and the rest that happens is left to interpretation like the first game.

Probably because she was in Shock and full of adrenaline especially when she broke her leg. When your in shock and full of adrenaline you tend not to express much emotion other then trying to survive

This is interesting I was expecting it to go one way or the other

And a bloater was in the basement too